Canada makes HIV prevention count

One of the current buzzwords in HIV is “combination prevention” — a polite way of saying that anything that works even a little bit should be on the menu. It’s a way of trying to tear people away from the kindergarten level “Abstinence works, No, no, condoms work, No, no, circumcision works, No, no, it’s all about clean needles” debate which has proved such an energy sink in recent years. And it’s much to be applauded (as long as it stays focused on things that really do work, even a little bit).

But “Maths works”? That’s a new one on me. “A team of Canadian graduate students and two leading mathematicians … will travel to Botswana next week for a workshop that aims to teach students how to control the spread of diseases through math equations and formulas“, according to Canada’s CBC.

Now I do a fair bit of modelling myself (of the mathematical kind, I hasten to add for those who’ve never seen me). I believe a good projection scenario can tickle a government in all sorts of useful ways. What if I spend all my money testing pregnant women, and none buying clean needles for drug injectors? What happens to my treatment bills if we teach schoolkids to cross their legs but don’t help gay men to recognise the first symptoms of HIV infection? Equations can make people think. They can conjour up the best of worlds and the worst. They can guesstimate budgets and generate column inches. But controlling the spread of diseases with equations? That takes a combination of nerdiness and hubris that I’ve not seen on any menu.

This post was published on 14/08/08 in Science.

Send this post to a friend Send this post to a friend

1 comment

You can follow the comments on this post via this RSS feed.

Tags: , , .

  1. Comment by Lee Rudolph, 15/08/08, 11:53:

    “But controlling the spread of diseases with equations? That takes a combination of nerdiness and hubris that I’ve not seen on any menu.”

    Blame it on the author of the MITACS press release, http://www.mitacs.ca/ CMS/ asset/ 143_2008-8-12-8-46-37_AfricaSummerSchool_FINAL_August12,2008. pdf , whose lede ends “how to control the spread of infectious diseases using equations and formulas”, and on whoever it was at Canada Press that rewrote the press release into something even more hubristic.

    The word “control” *does* appear inside quotation marks attributed to a mathematician in the press release: “The goal of this workshop is to equip these math students with the research skills so that they will be in a position to play integral roles in the control of diseases such as HIV/AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis.” Rather less hubristic, eh?

    But, as they say in the trade, the reason mathematicians aren’t allowed to write their own press releases is that they’d rather be correct than interesting.

    The pity is that so many journalists, including far too many of those whose beats are science, technology, and medicine, would rather (try to) be interesting than (strive to be) correct.

Comments are closed at this time.